Three conservation groups plan to sue the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service over the Birmingham darter. The agency missed a 90-day deadline to answer their November 2025 petition.

Overview

Three conservation groups said Thursday they intend to sue the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service over the Birmingham darter. The small fish lives only in the Valley Creek system in Jefferson County. The groups petitioned for federal protection in November 2025. The agency was due to give a first answer within 90 days and has not.

The Center for Biological Diversity, Alabama Rivers Alliance and Black Warrior Riverkeeper sent the agency a 60-day notice of intent to sue on Nov. 12. The notice letter went to Interior Secretary Doug Burgum and Fish and Wildlife Service leaders in Washington and Atlanta.

The groups say the agency has missed its legal deadline. Under the Endangered Species Act, the service must decide within 90 days of receiving a listing petition whether protection “may be warranted.” The Center filed its petition on Nov. 13, 2025. The letter says 330 days had passed without that finding.

If the agency does not publish a finding, or contact the groups to set a timeline, within 60 days, “we intend to file suit to enforce the ESA,” the letter said. The Center announced the notice in a news release Thursday.

A fish found in one creek system

The Birmingham darter, Etheostoma birminghamense, is about 2 inches long. It is one of six species in the vermilion darter group, according to the notice letter. The letter and the release give these facts about it:

  • it is known from only six populations
  • all six are in the Valley Creek system in Jefferson County
  • it has not been seen in Fivemile Creek since 2006, which the groups blame on quarrying there
  • the Alabama Department of Conservation and Natural Resources lists it as a species of “Highest Conservation Concern”

That state listing places no limits on the industries the groups blame for the fish’s decline, the letter said.

What the groups say threatens it

The letter says arsenic, nitrogen, mercury and total dissolved solids are elevated in the Valley Creek watershed. It ties that poor water quality to urban growth across Jefferson County.

The groups also name two proposed projects as new threats:

  • the Northern Beltline highway around Birmingham
  • the Project Marvel hyperscale data center near Bessemer

“Water pollution threats to the Birmingham darter’s habitat in Valley Creek and its tributaries are putting this rare endemic species at risk,” Nelson Brooke of Black Warrior Riverkeeper said in the release.

“Birmingham darters don’t have time for the Fish and Wildlife Service to slow-walk this decision,” said Laurel Jobe, an attorney at the Center.

Charles Miller, policy director at Alabama Rivers Alliance, said the service “must fulfill their statutory obligation and act swiftly to protect it.”

The petition also asked the agency to designate critical habitat for the darter at the same time as any listing. The full November 2025 petition is on the Center’s website.

What it means for you

Nothing changes for property owners or projects yet. A 90-day finding is only the first step. If the agency finds protection may be warranted, it starts a full review of the species. Any proposal to list the fish or map critical habitat would come later, with a public comment period.

If the darter were eventually listed, federal agencies would have to consider it before funding or permitting work that could affect Valley Creek and its tributaries. That would include highway and other federally permitted projects in the creek’s watershed.

The 60-day notice period from Nov. 12 runs to Jan. 11, 2027.

Frequently asked questions

What is the Birmingham darter?

A brightly colored freshwater fish about 2 inches long. It is known from only six populations, all in the Valley Creek system in Jefferson County.

Why do the groups plan to sue?

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service had to decide within 90 days whether their November 2025 petition to list the fish under the Endangered Species Act may be warranted. The groups say it has not made that decision.

When could a lawsuit be filed?

The notice dated Nov. 12 gives the agency 60 days to publish its finding or agree on a timeline with the groups. If it does neither, they say they will file suit.